Connect with us

Business

Can new authority resolve cybersecurity paradox? | The Express Tribune

Published

on

Can new authority resolve cybersecurity paradox? | The Express Tribune


Questions remain unanswered about funding, institutional coherence and tension with telecom firms


ISLAMABAD:

As the federal IT minister is all set to present the new Cybersecurity Act 2025 for establishing an independent National Cybersecurity Authority (NCA), fundamental questions remain unanswered regarding funding, institutional coherence, and the inherent tension between security and telecom companies.

The government has stated that new secure digital infrastructure will be built under the World Bank-backed Digital Economy Enhancement Project (DEEP). This strategic choice prompts a key question: why is a World Bank-funded project (DEEP), focused on digital public services, being positioned as the backbone for a national security law?

This proposed law pertains to the fourth component of the World Bank’s DEEP, which is Contingent Emergency Response Component (CERC) and is being financed with zero dollars and is primarily about development of a CERC manual that entails an emergency action plan. DEEP is specifically funding the assessment of Pakistan’s cybersecurity infrastructure and the development of a comprehensive cybersecurity roadmap by the end of this year.

By embedding the new Cybersecurity Act’s architecture directly into the DEEP project, the government is seeking to achieve two goals: tapping into international investments and standardisation.

NCA would utilise moderately sized international investment (DEEP) to finance the otherwise expensive development of secure, government-wide infrastructure, bypassing reliance solely on the national budget. At the same time, it shall enforce global best practices, as World Bank projects require stringent standards for data governance and security. Logically, these good practices could be then followed by our National CERT.

However, the question remains: what happens to the existing National Emergency Response Team (PK CERT) and will the Act lead to institutional redundancy? And what roles related to cybersecurity shall remain with the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA)?

PK CERT (Pakistan Computer Emergency Response Team) is the officially designated National CERT, formally established under the CERT Rules 2023 to handle cyber incident response, threat intelligence sharing, and coordination across national and sectoral CERTs.

Now establishing a new, overarching National Cybersecurity Authority with response powers could create bureaucratic overlaps with the operational functions already mandated to PK CERT. Will the NCA become the policymaking body while PK CERT remains the technical implementation arm, or will the NCA attempt to incorporate the functions of PK CERT in entirety?

Similarly, the PTA has its own comprehensive cybersecurity framework for the telecom sector that is built on six pillars of legal framework, cyber resilience, proactive monitoring and incident response, capacity building, cooperation and collaboration, and public awareness. Collectively, these pillars represent a holistic approach, ensuring a resilient and secure digital infrastructure across Pakistan’s telecom sector.

It remains to be seen whether the new Cybersecurity Act and the establishment of the National Cybersecurity Authority would rationalise or rather confuse the PTA’s security mandate?

The PTA currently operates under a regulatory framework focused on communication and content. The proposed NCA, however, is meant to be the apex technical and policy body for national cybersecurity. If the NCA focuses strictly on national defence and critical infrastructure protection, the PTA’s security role might be limited to telecom operators. This could lead to a clear division of labour.

But if conversely, the NCA demands sweeping powers over all digital infrastructure, it would create a conflict over who sets the technical standards for telecom networks – the established telecom regulator (PTA) or the new cyber authority (NCA).

The PTA’s current dual role as a regulator as well as an enforcer of censorship means its actions are often perceived through a lens of political control rather than technical security. The NCA must ensure that the overall cybersecurity strategy prioritises technical defence and rights protection over the PTA’s tendency towards mass restriction. So, the true test of the new framework is whether the NCA, as a high-level authority focused on technical resilience, will advocate for alternative, targeted security measures instead of blanket shutdowns enforced by the PTA.

In essence, the new Cybersecurity Act provides an opportunity to either formalise the PTA’s necessary security functions under the NCA’s umbrella, thereby improving coherence, or it could simply add another layer of bureaucracy, further muddying the lines of authority over Pakistan’s critical digital space. The need for a “beefed-up incident response” system is undeniable, but it must build on the technical expertise that PK CERT is tasked with developing.

If the new authority is primarily a political or bureaucratic body, it risks sidelining the technical competency of PK CERT, replacing expert-driven incident management with top-down political control.

A similar fiasco happened a few years back when we tried to transfer powers for managing state-owned companies to a newly established withholding company – Sarmaya-e-Pakistan – a move that totally backfired and resulted in wastage of taxpayers’ money.

The writer is a Cambridge graduate and is working as a strategy consultant



Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business

Trump raises potential concerns over $72bn Netflix-Warner Bros deal

Published

on

Trump raises potential concerns over bn Netflix-Warner Bros deal


US President Donald Trump has flagged potential concerns over Netflix’s planned $72bn (£54bn) deal to buy Warner Brothers Discovery’s movie studio and popular HBO streaming networks.

At an event in Washington DC on Sunday, he said Netflix has a “big market share” and the firms’ combined size “could be a problem”.

On Friday, the two companies said they had reached an agreement that could bring Warner Brothers’ franchises like Harry Potter and Game of Thrones to Netflix, creating a new media giant.

The planned deal, which has raised concerns among some in the industry, is yet to be approved by competition authorities. The BBC has contacted Warner Brothers, Netflix and the White House for comment.

Launched in 1997 as a postal DVD rental business, Netflix has grown to become the world’s largest subscription streaming service. The deal – the biggest the film industry has seen in a long time – would cement its number one position.

Under the agreement several global entertainment franchises, such as Looney Tunes, The Matrix and Lord of the Rings, would move to Netflix.

The US Justice Department’s competition division, which oversees major mergers, could contend that the deal violates the law if the combined businesses account for too much of the streaming market.

At an event at the John F. Kennedy Center in the US capital, Trump said that Netflix has a “very big market share” which would “go up by a lot” if the deal goes ahead.

Trump added that he would be personally involved in the decision on whether or not to approve the deal and repeatedly highlighted the size of Netflix’s market share.

He also said that Netflix’s co-CEO Ted Sarandos recently visited the Oval Office and praised him for his work at the company.

“I have a lot of respect for him. He’s a great person,” said Trump. “He’s done one of the greatest jobs in the history of movies.”

Mr Sarandos earlier acknowledged that the agreement may have surprised investors but said it was a chance to position Netflix for success in the “decades to come”.

Some in the entertainment industry have criticised the agreement.

The Writers Guild of America’s East and West branches called for the merger to be blocked, saying the “world’s largest streaming company swallowing one of its biggest competitors is what antitrust laws were designed to prevent.”

“The outcome would eliminate jobs, push down wages, worsen conditions for all entertainment workers, raise prices for consumers and reduce the volume and diversity of content for all viewers,” it said on Friday.



Source link

Continue Reading

Business

Ministers promise 50,000 new apprenticeships in bid to tackle youth unemployment

Published

on

Ministers promise 50,000 new apprenticeships in bid to tackle youth unemployment



Sir Keir Starmer is set to announce a major investment in apprenticeships on Monday in an effort to tackle rising youth unemployment.

Some 50,000 young people are expected to benefit from the £725 million investment, in which more apprenticeships will be created in sectors including AI, hospitality and engineering.

The Government is aiming to reverse a decline in the number of young people starting apprenticeships, which has fallen by almost 40% in the past decade.

The Prime Minister has also expressed his desire to see apprenticeships treated with the same respect as degree courses.

At this year’s Labour party conference, he said he wanted to see two-thirds of young people study for a degree or an apprenticeship.

Sir Keir said: “For too long, success has been measured by how many young people go to university. That narrow view has held back opportunity and created barriers we need to break.

“If you choose an apprenticeship, you should have the same respect and opportunity as everyone else.”

Sir Keir will mark the announcement with a visit to McLaren’s technology centre near Woking, in Surrey on Monday, where he will meet apprentices and other young people at the start of their careers.

McLaren, whose driver Lando Norris won the Formula 1 championship on Sunday, employs 84 people in its early careers scheme and is developing apprenticeships in a range of areas to increase that number.

The funding, which covers the next three years, includes a commitment to fully fund apprenticeships at small and medium-sized businesses.

It also includes £140 million for regional mayors to link young people not in employment, education or training (Neet) with local apprenticeships.

Ministers have been especially concerned with the rising number of young people classed as Neets, which experts suggest is on course to exceed one million for the first time since the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis.

On Sunday, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden announced an £820 million investment in tackling the Neet problem, including more training and guaranteed jobs for long-term out-of-work young people.

He said: “This funding is a downpayment on young people’s futures and the future of the country, creating real pathways into good jobs and providing work experience, skills training and guaranteed employment.”

The Government is also expected to set out its national youth strategy this week.

Speaking to the BBC’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg, Mr McFadden said young people had “not had a good enough deal” in areas such as housing and employment.

He said: “Young people do need a better deal. They need a Government that believes in them.”



Source link

Continue Reading

Business

Bridging the gap for digital future | The Express Tribune

Published

on

Bridging the gap for digital future | The Express Tribune


Although Pakistan has rapidly growing digital population, its research spending and industrial automation remain limit

Pakistan, by contrast, has opted out of the ITA, one of the world’s most successful digital trade agreements, whose membership has grown to 86 countries accounting for over 97% of global digital trade.: photo: file


KARACHI:

The global economy is undergoing a seismic technological shift. Robotics, automation, and AI are no longer futuristic ideas, they are now mainstream drivers of productivity, competitiveness, and innovation.

According to the International Federation of Robotics (IFR), the industries worldwide deployed over 553,000 new industrial robots in 2023, marking a historic peak in automation demand. Meanwhile, global AI investment is projected to exceed $300 billion by 2026, as estimated by the International Data Corporation (IDC). The world is accelerating rapidly, but Pakistan risks being left behind unless decisive and strategic action is taken.

Pakistan’s current standing in global technological competitiveness reflects this urgent need. The World Intellectual Property Organisation’s Global Innovation Index 2024 ranked Pakistan 88 out of 132 countries, trailing significantly behind regional peers such as India (40), China (12), and even Iran (62).

Although Pakistan has a young and rapidly growing digital population, its innovation input including research spending, patenting, STEM education quality, and industrial automation remains limited.

One of the clearest indicators of Pakistan’s lag is its extremely low adoption of industrial robotics. While China deployed more than 290,000 robots in 2023, India installed over 4,000, and Southeast Asian economies like Vietnam and Thailand each installed several thousand per year, Pakistan’s installations remain negligible estimated in the low hundreds, primarily within automotive assembly and select textile units. This places Pakistan far below global benchmarks for robotics penetration per 10,000 manufacturing workers, a critical indicator used by the IFR.

AI development, too, is growing slowly despite considerable potential. Estimates suggest Pakistan’s AI industry is currently valued at around $100-120 million, a fraction of India’s AI ecosystem, which already exceeds $7.8 billion in valuation.

Global tech corporations and venture investors have poured tens of billions of dollars into the research and deployment of AI models, automation platforms, and robotics labs. Pakistan, however, lacks a cohesive national AI strategy, consistent funding pipelines, or large-scale industrial automation programmes that could unlock similar growth.

Pakistan has strong foundations that can be leveraged. The country produces more than 35,000 IT and engineering graduates annually, according to the Higher Education Commission (HEC). Freelancers and digital workers generate over $400 million in annual export earnings, reflecting global demand for Pakistani technical talent. Moreover, private-sector initiatives from robotics startups in Karachi and Lahore to automation efforts in large industrial groups demonstrate that capacity exists when given the right incentives and resources.

Pakistan must pivot from scattered initiatives to a coordinated national strategy. Three priority areas stand out. First, the country must invest in industrial automation at scale. The manufacturing sector, which accounts for nearly 12-13% of GDP, suffers from low productivity, energy inefficiencies, and technology gaps.

Robotics adoption in textiles, food processing, pharmaceuticals, and logistics can significantly increase competitiveness in export markets. Government-backed tax incentives for robotics equipment, low-interest automation loans, and partnerships with countries like China, South Korea, and Japan could accelerate industrial modernisation.

Second, research and development (R&D) must be strengthened. Pakistan’s gross expenditure on R&D stands at less than 0.3% of GDP, far below the global average of 2.3%, and dramatically lower than innovation leaders like South Korea (4.9%) or China (2.4%).

Without substantial investment in university labs, applied AI research centres, and industry-academia partnerships, Pakistan cannot produce the intellectual property or advanced technical solutions required for robotics and AI advancement. Establishing National Robotics Centres, funded jointly by the government and private industry, would be a game-changing step.

Third, talent development and regulation should be prioritised. Pakistan urgently needs specialised curricula in AI engineering, machine learning, robotics design, control systems, and industrial automation. Short courses and certifications are not enough. Universities should embed practical robotics labs and co-op industry training into degree programmes.

Simultaneously, Pakistan must design a forward-looking regulatory framework for AI ethics, data governance, cybersecurity, and safe deployment. Without clear guardrails, industries will hesitate to invest.

The government’s recent efforts such as the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) targeting technology investment, and the Ministry of IT’s proposed National AI Strategy indicate growing recognition of the need for reform. But policy action has been slow, funding remains thin, and coordination across ministries is limited. If Pakistan wants to harness global shifts in automation and AI, it must treat technology as a central pillar of economic policy, not a peripheral sector.

The World Economic Forum estimates that AI and automation could generate $15.7 trillion in global economic value by 2030. Countries that integrate robotics into manufacturing and AI into services will gain a decisive productivity advantage.

Pakistan’s export industries, already struggling with high input costs and low efficiency, risk losing global market share if they fail to modernise. Conversely, with the right policies, Pakistan could unlock a new wave of technology-driven growth, create high-value jobs, and transform its industrial base.

The “robotics and AI race” is not about machines replacing people; it is about countries equipping their people with the tools needed to compete in a world powered by automation. Pakistan has the youth, the talent, and the strategic geographic position to participate meaningfully in this global transformation. What it lacks is coordinated investment, regulatory clarity, and long-term technological vision.

The message for Pakistan’s policymakers and business leaders is clear: the world is not waiting. Robotics and AI are reshaping global trade, industry, and innovation at unprecedented speed. Pakistan must act now decisively and strategically or risk being left on the sidelines of the new digital economy.

The writer is a member of PEC and has a masters in Engineering



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending