Connect with us

Business

I blew the whistle on a massive tax fraud – and they sued me

Published

on

I blew the whistle on a massive tax fraud – and they sued me


Theo LeggettBusiness Correspondent

Jas Bains A man who appears to be in his 30s - he is sitting on a sofa at home, wearing a light off-white t-shirt, and smiling, clearly relaxed in the setting - he is leaning on the arm of the sofa with his left arm, and his watch is visible Jas Bains

Jas Bains alerted Danish authorities to a £1bn tax scam and they hit him with a lawsuit

“We’d be met at airports in 20-foot limousines, and taken to places like the Atlantis hotel in Dubai or the Singapore Grand Prix. There’d be a hundred grand spent in the bar.”

In 2013, Jas Bains was an ambitious young lawyer, enjoying the high life that came with working for an extremely profitable City hedge fund.

Today, he is jobless and has lost most of his wealth, having spent years fighting legal battles and attempting to clear his name of association with a huge tax scam.

The irony, he says, is that he blew the whistle on the scam in the first place – only to find himself one of the targets of a £1.4bn lawsuit.

He is reflecting one month after the case ended, bringing to a close eight years of legal arguments and one of the highest value civil cases ever heard in the UK.

The Danish tax authority was left licking its wounds, after failing to establish that a large group of defendants, including Mr Bains, were liable for huge losses it had suffered.

It all began in 2009, when a banker named Sanjay Shah established a London-based hedge fund called Solo Capital. It also had offices in Dubai. It was one of a network of funds, banks and legal outfits that were to become heavily implicated in the so-called cum-ex trade.

This focused on transactions where shares were sold from one investor to another immediately before the payment of a dividend (cum, or with, dividend) but delivered afterwards (ex-dividend).

Those involved exploited delays in processing the sale to create confusion over who actually owned the shares at the moment when the dividend was paid. This tactic allowed both parties to claim rebates on withholding tax – a levy which had only been paid once, when the dividend was issued.

From the outside, it was complicated, but for those involved it led to ever bigger and more elaborate trades which ultimately cost taxpayers across Europe billions.

It initially became popular in Germany, before spreading to other countries including France, Belgium, Italy and Austria. Solo Capital targeted Denmark, with the bulk of its cum-ex trades taking place from 2013 onwards.

Jas Bains joined the company in 2010, as its head lawyer, but went on to run the London office. At the time, Solo was “a successful firm, making money in five or six different areas pretty well”.

Getty Images Sanjay Shah standing outside underneath trees in what appears to be a garden in a built up office area - he is a middle aged man, with a white shirt and thinning hair. He is looking just past the camera with a neutral expression. Getty Images

Sanjay Shah was imprisoned in Denmark in a separate criminal trial last year

And making money meant enjoying the high life, with staff going on sprees to places like Las Vegas, Singapore and Dubai.

“What I will say about Sanjay is he knew how to throw a party,” he says.

“One time we were in the Ku De Ta club at the Marina Bay Sands Hotel in Singapore. He bought 20 bottles of vintage Dom Perignon champagne, and people were just spraying each other with the stuff.

“People have likened it to Wolf of Wall Street and such like.”

It didn’t end there. “Sanjay organised private concerts in Dubai with Prince. A small room with him and his friends at three or four million dollars for an evening … private concerts with Snoop Dogg.”

By mid-2014, however, Mr Bains had fallen out with his boss and left the company for a competitor. At the time, the cum-ex transactions targeting Denmark were dramatically picking up.

“I was hearing from people who’d left Solo that Sanjay was doing some big trades in 2014, but look, I’d moved on, it didn’t have much to do with me,” he says.

“But then I heard, actually Sanjay made close to €100m in trades from Denmark in 2013, closer to €250m in 2014 and he was looking for a billion in 2015.”

Alarm bells were ringing.

Jas Bains Jas Bains in a smart suit in a swanky bar restaurant talking to people who are out of shotJas Bains

At the height of his career Jas Bains enjoyed living the high life in Las Vegas, Singapore and Dubai.

“I thought this can’t be right. It’s not that I thought the trades were invalid or criminal in some way. It’s just any country that has a billion Euros syphoned off it will scream bloody murder.”

Solo Capital wasn’t the only company now targeting Denmark. Others were getting in on the act. Jas believed it was only a matter of time before the house of cards came tumbling down.

“I was quite confident I’d done nothing wrong, but I knew if this carried on and blew up in spectacular style, I was going to get pulled in,” he explains.

With that in mind, in 2015, he decided to blow the whistle.

He contacted a Danish lawyer, who in turn put him in touch with the Danish police. He went on to spend two and a half years assisting them with understanding how the cum-ex scam worked.

Danish prosecutors did not target Mr Bains. Their attention was focused firmly on Mr Shah. The 54-year-old was eventually extradited from Dubai to face fraud charges – and in December last year was sentenced to 12 years in jail.

It was the heaviest penalty ever handed out in Denmark for a fraud case. He is currently appealing.

‘Impossible to get a job’

But when the Danish tax authority, Skatteforvaltningen (Skat), launched its huge case, seeking to recover its lost money, Mr Bains was one of the more than 100 individual and corporate defendants initially targeted – alongside Mr Shah.

With that lawsuit hanging over him it became out of the question for him to work as a lawyer, or to get a role in the City of London.

“It’s impossible to get a job if you’re being sued as part of a two billion dollar international tax fraud case,” he says.

However, in October, High court judge Mr Justice Andrew Baker threw out Skat’s claims.

Acknowledging that “greed can be a powerful motive, and I consider there was substantial greed here”, he nevertheless concluded that Skat has failed to prove it was a victim of deception.

The authority’s “controls for assessing and paying dividend tax refund claims were so flimsy as to be non-existent,” he said.

That seemed to echo a statement previously made by Mr Shah in a 2021 German TV interview, which was also cited in the ruling:

“Why would they pay out for years and years and then, after four years of payments they say, ‘Oh, we made a mistake, or we were cheated'”, he said.

“If there’s a big sign on the street saying ‘please help yourself’, then me or somebody else would go and help themselves.”

There may still be an appeal. But for Mr Bains, the ruling provided some much-needed closure – and, he says, a chance to move on.



Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business

Govt orders faster city gas project clearances, hikes commercial LPG allocation to ease supply stress – The Times of India

Published

on

Govt orders faster city gas project clearances, hikes commercial LPG allocation to ease supply stress – The Times of India


The government has stepped up efforts to streamline gas distribution and ease supply pressures, directing faster processing of city gas projects while increasing allocations of commercial LPG to key sectors amid a challenging geopolitical environment.The Petroleum and Explosives Safety Organisation (PESO) has instructed its offices to dispose of City Gas Distribution (CGD) applications within 10 days, aiming to accelerate the rollout of piped natural gas (PNG), an official statement said.Commercial LPG consumers in major cities and urban areas have also been advised to shift to PNG as part of a broader strategy to reduce dependence on liquefied petroleum gas. Domestic LPG supply remains stable, with no reported dry-outs at distributorships and normal delivery patterns across the country, the statement said, adding that most deliveries are being carried out through the Delivery Authentication Code (DAC) while panic bookings have subsided, PTI reported.On the commercial LPG front, the government has progressively increased allocations. After restoring 20 per cent supply earlier, an additional 10 per cent allocation linked to PNG expansion reforms was announced on March 18. A further 20 per cent allocation was cleared on March 21, taking total commercial LPG supply to 50 per cent.The latest increase prioritises sectors such as restaurants, dhabas, hotels, industrial canteens, food processing units, dairy operations, community kitchens and subsidised food outlets run by state governments and local bodies. Provision has also been made for 5 kg cylinders for migrant workers.Around 20 states and Union Territories have implemented the revised allocation guidelines, while public sector oil marketing companies are supplying commercial LPG in the remaining regions. In the past eight days, about 15,440 tonnes of LPG have been lifted by commercial entities.Educational institutions and hospitals continue to receive priority, accounting for nearly half of the total commercial LPG allocation. Despite global uncertainties affecting supply, the government indicated that domestic availability remains under control while efforts continue to transition urban consumers towards PNG.



Source link

Continue Reading

Business

UK inflation steady but experts warn of cost-of-living ‘twist’ in months ahead

Published

on

UK inflation steady but experts warn of cost-of-living ‘twist’ in months ahead


Experts have warned of another “twist” to the cost-of-living story in the months ahead, as war in the Middle East is set to send energy bills soaring.

The rate of Consumer Prices Index (CPI) inflation has been gradually easing back towards the Bank of England’s two per cent target level since last summer.

Some analysts are expecting CPI to have held relatively steady in February, or dipped slightly, from the three per cent level recorded in January.

Official figures for last month will be published on Wednesday.

Economists for Deutsche Bank and Pantheon Macroeconomics said they are anticipating CPI to hold steady at three per cent in February, with lower fuel and services inflation being offset by higher clothes prices and air fares.

Edward Allenby, senior economist for Oxford Economics, said he thinks CPI inflation fell to 2.8 per cent in February, largely thanks to a predicted fall in petrol prices and slower inflation in the services sector.

Analysts for Barclays said they are expecting the headline rate to dip to 2.9 per cent, also partly because of lower pump prices during the month.

But Sanjay Raja, Deutsche Bank’s chief UK economist, said the inflation outlook has “rarely been more uncertain than it is now”.

He wrote in a research note: “We expect the UK’s disinflation story will take another twist on its (eventual) way down to target.

“The good news is that CPI is still expected to slide down in the coming months.

“The bad news? Higher energy prices appear poised to lift CPI meaningfully over the summer, adding yet another hump in the inflation profile.”

The Bank of England raised its inflation forecasts for the months ahead on Thursday
The Bank of England raised its inflation forecasts for the months ahead on Thursday (PA)

Economists have been ripping up previous projections in recent days and warning that the US-Israel war with Iran has muddied the outlook for the economy.

The Bank of England said on Thursday that recent increases in wholesale energy costs would delay the return of CPI inflation to target, as it was already seeing higher fuel prices.

It is now expecting inflation to be around three per cent in the second quarter of 2026, up from the 2.1 per cent that had been forecast in February.

The central bankers stressed that the situation is volatile and events over the next six weeks could shed light on the scale of the disruption and impact on prices.

Economists have weighed in with their own projections of where inflation could go if things persist.

Mr Allenby said he is now expecting CPI inflation to exceed four per cent during the second half of 2026.

“Under our updated assumptions, we now anticipate a much sharper rise in petrol prices, while higher wholesale gas prices cause a 19 per cent increase in the Ofgem energy price cap in July,” he said.

Pantheon Macroeconomics agreed that, if the latest spike in gas prices is sustained, then CPI could be headed to four per cent later this yar.



Source link

Continue Reading

Business

Sky‑high losses: Iran war drives airlines to biggest crash since Covid – $50bn gone – The Times of India

Published

on

Sky‑high losses: Iran war drives airlines to biggest crash since Covid – bn gone – The Times of India


Global airlines have suffered their worst financial shock since the COVID‑19 pandemic as the ongoing war involving US Israel and Iran has disrupted industry operations, wiping more than $50 billion off the market value of the world’s largest carriers amid rising fears of fuel shortages.The conflict, now entering its fourth week, has grounded flights, disrupted key Gulf hub airports and driven jet fuel prices sharply higher, compounding pressure on an industry that was rebounding strongly following pandemic‑related losses.According to Financial Times calculations, the 20 largest publicly listed airlines have collectively lost about $53 billion in market capitalisation since the war began. In response, airline executives have warned of a potential rise in ticket prices as carriers seek to protect shrinking profit margins.Jet fuel, which accounts for roughly a third of operating costs for airlines, has doubled in price since the United States and Israel launched attacks on Iran at the end of February. Many carriers had hedged against fuel price swings, but the rapid rise is expected to force airlines to pass on costs to passengers.“Fuel spiked quite heavily after the Ukraine invasion in 2022 as well, but this has gone further north,” easyJet chief executive Kenton Jarvis told FT, describing the current crisis as the most significant upheaval since the pandemic closed global skies in 2020.Executives also point to broader structural challenges, including the risk that sustained high fares may dampen demand. Carsten Spohr, CEO of Lufthansa, said higher ticket prices were unavoidable but expressed concern that they could weaken long‑term demand. “Our average profit is about €10 per passenger, there’s no way you can absorb the additional cost,” he said.In addition to passenger traffic pressures, airlines are preparing contingency plans for possible jet fuel shortages. Air France‑KLM CEO Ben Smith said the carrier is drawing up measures to cope with potential supply squeezes, including scaling back services on some Asian routes.The crisis has hit Middle Eastern carriers particularly hard. Carriers such as Emirates, Etihad and Qatar Airways have had to sharply reduce schedules due to airspace closures and a collapse in regional tourism, industry officials say. Despite the severity of the current disruption, Willie Walsh, head of the International Air Transport Association (IATA), noted that it still falls short of the pandemic’s impact but is reminiscent of the downturn in transatlantic demand after the 9/11 attacks, according to FT.

Poll

What should airlines prioritize during the current crisis?

The conflict’s ripple effects are also visible in cargo operations, as freight traffic shifts from disrupted shipping routes to air cargo, straining airport facilities. At Geneva airport, for example, freight re‑routing has led to overflow onto services bound for Paris.Industry observers remain hopeful that airline valuations and demand will rebound once the conflict abates. “The share price has moved against all airlines since the start of the conflict,” Jarvis said, adding that short sellers would likely close positions quickly if a ceasefire is announced.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending