Business
The ‘Net economy’ | The Express Tribune
KARACHI:
Pakistan’s economic discourse has long been dominated by familiar concerns: fiscal deficits, balance of payments pressures, and the performance of traditional export sectors such as textiles and agriculture. Yet, beneath these recurring challenges, a structural shift is quietly reshaping the economy.
The country’s digital or “net” economy – anchored in IT services, freelancing, and a rapidly expanding content creator ecosystem – is emerging as a credible and scalable engine of growth. In 2025, this transformation can no longer be dismissed as peripheral.
The most visible expression of this shift is the rise of Pakistani content creators on global digital platforms, particularly YouTube. What began as isolated experimentation has evolved into a structured ecosystem of digital enterprises that earn foreign exchange, create employment, and project Pakistan’s cultural identity to global audiences. Running parallel to this is the strong performance of Pakistan’s IT and IT-enabled services exports, which have reached record levels and now form a key pillar of services trade.
Recent platform data indicates that Pakistan hosts more than 95,000 YouTube channels with over 10,000 subscribers – a threshold generally associated with sustainable monetisation. More than 13,000 channels have crossed the 100,000-subscriber mark, while over 1,000 channels boast more than one million subscribers. These figures reflect not merely popularity, but the scale of a growing digital workforce embedded in global markets.
Each successful channel functions as a small enterprise. Beyond the creator, there are editors, scriptwriters, designers, animators, camera operators, and social media managers. This ecosystem is generating thousands of jobs, many of them flexible, skill-based, and location-independent – characteristics well aligned with Pakistan’s youthful labour force and constrained domestic job market.
One of the most striking aspects of Pakistan’s creator economy is its international reach. Industry analysis suggests that over 60% of watch time on Pakistani YouTube content originates from outside the country. This marks a decisive shift from domestic consumption to digital exports. Pakistani creators are increasingly producing content for global audiences while remaining physically based at home, earning revenue in foreign currency.
Certain genres have proven particularly effective. Food and culinary content attract global viewers seeking authenticity. Travel and rural-life vlogs showcase landscapes and lifestyles rarely visible in international media. Educational explainers, lifestyle programming, and family vlogs also perform strongly, especially on connected television platforms where long-form content thrives.
Channels such as Kitchen with Amna and Village Food Secrets illustrate how culturally rooted content can achieve global resonance. Their success highlights a key advantage of the digital economy: high export potential with relatively low capital requirements. Authenticity, consistency, and storytelling often matter more than production budgets.
The economic implications are significant. Conservative estimates suggest that a YouTube channel with over one million subscribers can earn between $50,000 and $200,000 annually, depending on niche, engagement, and audience geography. With more than 1,000 such channels, Pakistan’s YouTube economy alone could be generating $50-$200 million per year in foreign revenue. Much of this income flows directly into Pakistan, supporting household incomes and contributing to external account stability. Beyond earnings, creators contribute to Pakistan’s soft power. Through humour, food, travel, and social commentary, they present nuanced portrayals of Pakistani society that counter stereotypes and enhance international visibility in ways traditional diplomacy often cannot.
While the creator economy is highly visible, it represents only one layer of a broader digital export story. Pakistan’s IT and IT-enabled services sector has posted record performance in recent years. In fiscal year 2024-25, IT and ITeS exports crossed $3.8 billion, with monthly figures through 2025 repeatedly setting new records. This growth reflects sustained global demand rather than temporary spikes.
IT exports now account for a significant share of Pakistan’s services exports and have become one of the most reliable sources of foreign exchange. Pakistani firms provide software development, mobile and web applications, cloud services, cybersecurity solutions, and business process outsourcing to clients across North America, Europe, the Gulf, and Asia.
Freelancers form another critical pillar of this digital economy. Pakistan is among the world’s leading suppliers of freelance digital services, with professionals engaged in programming, design, content creation, and digital marketing. Freelancing contributes hundreds of millions of dollars annually in foreign exchange and continues to expand as global demand for remote work grows.
From a macroeconomic perspective, the significance of digital exports is substantial. IT and ICT services have consistently generated trade surpluses within the services account, helping offset chronic deficits in goods trade. At a time when external financing options are limited, digital exports offer a relatively stable and scalable source of foreign earnings.
Another dimension often overlooked in discussions on the net economy is its role in economic resilience and shock absorption. Unlike traditional export sectors, which are vulnerable to global commodity cycles, logistics disruptions, and geopolitical tensions, digital exports are inherently more agile. IT services, freelancing, and content creation depend primarily on human capital and connectivity rather than physical supply chains.
During periods of currency volatility or import compression, digital exporters can continue earning foreign exchange with minimal reliance on imported inputs. This structural advantage positions the net economy as a stabilising force in an otherwise fragile macroeconomic environment.
Equally important is the net economy’s potential to reduce brain drain without restricting mobility. For decades, Pakistan has exported talent while importing value, as skilled professionals migrated abroad in search of opportunity. Digital work offers an alternative: global income without physical migration. Software engineers, designers, educators, and creators can serve international markets while remaining rooted locally. This ensures that earnings circulate within the domestic economy, strengthens household resilience, and preserves human capital that would otherwise be lost.
Looking ahead, the potential scale of Pakistan’s net economy is considerable. If current trends persist, IT and IT-enabled services exports could reach $8-10 billion annually by the end of the decade. Digital services would then stand alongside textiles as one of Pakistan’s top export earners.
The creator economy is also poised for expansion. With continued platform growth and improved monetisation strategies, the number of Pakistani channels with over 100,000 subscribers could exceed 20,000 by 2030. Combined creator revenues – including sponsorships and merchandising – could approach $1 billion annually, with significant spillover effects for employment and allied services.
However, this potential will not be realised automatically. Regulatory clarity remains limited, particularly around taxation and income classification for freelancers and creators. Uncertainty discourages formalisation and full revenue repatriation.
Predictable, export-friendly policies are essential. Infrastructure gaps also persist. Reliable electricity, high-speed internet, and efficient digital payment systems are prerequisites for sustained growth. While urban centres have improved, many rural and semi-urban areas remain under-connected.
Skill development presents another constraint. Although Pakistan produces a large number of graduates, shortages persist in advanced areas such as artificial intelligence, cloud computing, cybersecurity, and data analytics. Content creators, meanwhile, often rely on self-taught skills that limit scalability. Structured training could significantly raise productivity and earnings. To fully harness the net economy, policymakers must treat digital exports as a strategic priority rather than a side activity. Stable tax regimes, simplified compliance, infrastructure investment, and targeted skill development can accelerate growth. Educational institutions must align curricula with global digital demand, while public-private partnerships can support incubation and international market access.
The writer is a Mechanical Engineer
Business
Stock market today: Nifty50 opens below 25,950; BSE Sensex down over 100 points – The Times of India
Stock market today: Indian equity benchmark indices, Nifty50 and BSE Sensex, opened in red on Tuesday on weak global cues. While Nifty50 went below 25,950, BSE Sensex was down over 120 points. At 9:19 AM, Nifty50 was trading at 25,902.85, down 39 points or 0.15%. BSE Sensex was at 84,567.40, down 128 points or 0.15%.According to experts, the stock market is expected to remain range bound in the near term, with investors closely tracking macroeconomic cues and institutional fund flows for direction.Dr. VK Vijayakumar, Chief Investment Strategist, Geojit Investments Limited says, “The year-end trend, though weak, doesn’t indicate a directional change in the market. The advance-decline ratio was far in favour of declines and this led to decline in Nifty by 100 points yesterday. But it is important to note that this decline happened on thin volumes. A clear directional change will happen only early in the new year when large institutions are back in action.”“It would be better for investors to watch the market now and wait for new triggers and new directional moves. However, weakness in the market can be used to nibble at high quality large caps. The auto sales numbers expected in two days will give an indication of the sustainability of the consumption boom in the economy. This is significant from the economic growth perspective, too.”Global cues were mixed as Wall Street’s key indices ended lower on Monday, starting the final week of the year on a weak note. The decline was led by heavyweight technology stocks, which retreated after last week’s rally had pushed the S&P 500 to record highs.Asian markets on Tuesday mirrored the cautious sentiment, with a seven day rally in regional stocks coming to a pause as technology led losses in the US spilled over. Precious metals also showed volatility, with gold and silver fluctuating after slipping from fresh all time highs.In currency markets, the US dollar traded steady on Tuesday ahead of the Federal Reserve’s release of minutes from its December policy meeting. On the domestic front, foreign portfolio investors continued to pare their exposure, selling equities worth Rs 2,760 crore on Monday. Domestic institutional investors, however, provided support to the market, emerging as net buyers to the tune of Rs 2,643 crore.(Disclaimer: Recommendations and views on the stock market, other asset classes or personal finance management tips given by experts are their own. These opinions do not represent the views of The Times of India)
Business
China plans strict AI rules to protect children and tackle suicide risks
Osmond ChiaBusiness reporter
Getty ImagesChina has proposed strict new rules for artificial intelligence (AI) to provide safeguards for children and prevent chatbots from offering advice that could lead to self-harm or violence.
Under the planned regulations, developers will also need to ensure their AI models do not generate content that promotes gambling.
The announcement comes after a surge in the number of chatbots being launched in China and around the world.
Once finalised, the rules will apply to AI products and services in China, marking a major move to regulate the fast-growing technology, which has come under intense scrutiny over safety concerns this year.
The draft rules, which were published at the weekend by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC), include measures to protect children. They include requiring AI firms to offer personalised settings, have time limits on usage and getting consent from guardians before providing emotional companionship services.
Chatbot operators must have a human take over any conversation related to suicide or self-harm and immediately notify the user’s guardian or an emergency contact, the administration said.
AI providers must ensure that their services do not generate or share “content that endangers national security, damages national honour and interests [or] undermines national unity”, the statement said.
The CAC said it encourages the adoption of AI, such as to promote local culture and create tools for companionship for the elderly, provided that the technology is safe and reliable. It also called for feedback from the public.
Chinese AI firm DeepSeek made headlines worldwide this year after it topped app download charts.
This month, two Chinese startups Z.ai and Minimax, which together have tens of millions of users, announced plans to list on the stock market.
The technology has quickly gained huge numbers of subscribers with some using it for companionship or therapy.
The impact of AI on human behaviour has come under increased scrutiny in recent months.
Sam Altman, the head of ChatGPT-maker OpenAI, said this year that the way chatbots respond to conversations related to self-harm is among the company’s most difficult problems.
In August, a family in California sued OpenAI over the death of their 16-year-old son, alleging that ChatGPT encouraged him to take his own life. The lawsuit marked the first legal action accusing OpenAI of wrongful death.
This month, the company advertised for a “head of preparedness” who will be responsible for defending against risks from AI models to human mental health and cybersecurity.
The successful candidate will be responsible for tracking AI risks that could pose a harm to people. Mr Altman said: “This will be a stressful job, and you’ll jump into the deep end pretty much immediately.”
If you are suffering distress or despair and need support, you could speak to a health professional, or an organisation that offers support. Details of help available in many countries can be found at Befrienders Worldwide: www.befrienders.org.
In the UK, a list of organisations that can help is available at bbc.co.uk/actionline. Readers in the US and Canada can call the 988 suicide helpline or visit its website.
Business
At 6.7%, IIP growth hits over 2-year high – The Times of India
Gaining momentum
.The manufacturing sector rose by 8% in Nov, higher than 2% in Oct and above the 5.5% in Nov last year. The mining sector, which had been impacted by unseasonal rains, rebounded and rose by 5.4% in Nov, above the 1.8% contraction in Oct and higher than the 1.9% growth in Nov last year.The highlight for Nov was also the robust expansion in consumer durables and non durables sectors, which grew by 10.3% and 7.3% respectively. “On the demand front, the positive aspect was the improvement in the output of consumer durables and non-durables which grew by 10.3% and 7.3%, respectively, reversing the contraction seen in the previous months. Factors such as GST rationalisation, income tax relief, and easing inflation have boded well for the consumption scenario,” said Rajani Sinha, chief economist at ratings agency CareEdge.“On the investment front, there has been sustained healthy momentum in the growth of infrastructure/construction goods and capital goods output,” said Sinha.The capital goods sector, a key gauge of investment activity, rose an annual 10.4% higher than the 2.1% recorded last month and above the 8.9% expansion in the month of Nov last year.Aditi Nayar, chief economist at ratings agency Icra, said the impact of the US tariffs and penalties is likely to reflect across some of the manufacturing segments, partly offsetting the positive impact of the GST rate rejig. “However, electricity demand has expanded in Dec 2025 after a gap of two months, which should boost power generation in the month, auguring well for IIP growth in the month. We expect the IIP growth to ease to 3.5-5.0% in Dec, as the base effect normalises and the benefit from restocking wanes,” said Nayar.
-
Sports3 days agoBrooks Koepka should face penalty if he rejoins PGA Tour, golf pundit says
-
Sports1 week agoPatriots vs. Ravens (Dec 21, 2025) Live Score – ESPN
-
Politics1 week agoUS intercepts oil tanker off Venezuelan coast, Reports
-
Business3 days agoGovt registers 144olive startups | The Express Tribune
-
Entertainment1 week agoDave Chappelle drops Netflix special, ‘Dave Chappelle: The Unstoppable…’
-
Business1 week agoNeptune Logitek Shares List At 26% Discount, IPO Investors Suffer Nearly Rs 30,000 Losses
-
Sports1 week agoWATCH: Pakistan’s winning moment as Green Shirts clinch U19 Asia Cup title
-
Entertainment1 week agoPentatonix sings “Christmas Time Is Here”
